15 tomes sit here under black magic, white magic and dark magic. The table uses the same columns as the weapons list, and the guide rates tomes by the same written rule, which is under “How these ratings are made”. Spells that a unit learns as it ranks up are on the spells page; this section covers the tomes you can carry, buy or find.
How these ratings are made
Game8, game8.jp and AppMedia each rank weapons. Each label is scored from 5 (top) to 2, and the guide takes the mean of the lists that rate a weapon: S from 4.6, A from 3.8, B from 2.8, C from 2.0, D below. Weapons are rated fully refined, the way those lists rate them.
A weapon no list rates gets an estimate from its stats, never above B: 3 points if its might is at or above the median for its weapon type, otherwise 2; plus 1 if it is accurate (hit 85 or more) and light (weight 5 or less); minus 1 for hit under 65 or weight over 12; minus 1 for 5 uses or fewer; minus 1 for plain Wooden, Bronze and Iron gear; minus 1 if cursed. With a stat missing, it is not rated. Magic with 5 charges or fewer gets no estimate at all: those spells are situational, and a stats score can’t judge them.
A rating with a ◇ beside it is a call the guide author made in their own play, with the reason given on the weapon’s page. The plate is the unit tier scale, S to D.
Plates use the unit tier scale, S best to D. A filled plate is this guide’s rating; an outline plate is the site vote once five people have voted.
- Blizzard† unverifiedMt 4 · Hit 80 · Crit 5 · Wt 6 · Rng 1-2 · 7 usesGuide◇ our recommendation: this guide's estimate; no published list rates it
- Bolganone† unverifiedMt 10 · Hit 85 · Crit 0 · Wt 8 · Rng 1-2 · 5 usesNot yet rated
- Cutting Gale† unverifiedMt 7 · Hit 95 · Crit 5 · Wt 8 · Rng 1-2 · 8 usesGuide◇ our recommendation: this guide's estimate; no published list rates it
- Fire† unverifiedMt 3 · Hit 90 · Crit 0 · Wt 5 · Rng 1-2 · 10 usesGuide◇ our recommendation: this guide's estimate; no published list rates it
- Glass Wheel† unverifiedMt 12 · Hit 90 · Crit 0 · Wt 7 · Rng 1-2 · 7 usesGuide◇ our recommendation: this guide's estimate; no published list rates it
- Thunder† unverifiedMt 5 · Hit 75 · Crit 0 · Wt 7 · Rng 1-2 · 8 usesGuide◇ our recommendation: this guide's estimate; no published list rates it
- Wandering Wall† unverifiedRng 1 · 5 usesNot yet rated
- Wind† unverifiedMt 3 · Hit 100 · Crit 0 · Wt 3 · Rng 1-2 · 10 usesGuide◇ our recommendation: this guide's estimate; no published list rates it
Last updated . Written and checked by the guide author; every record names its sources. See how this guide is sourced and what changed.
